May 2014

Just like Cicero

"Libertas, quae non in eo est ut iusto utamur domino, sed ut nullo," wrote Marcus Tullius Cicero. “Liberty, which does not consist in slavery to a just master, but in slavery to no master at all”. The quote is from De re publica (II, 43). Written between 55 BC and 51 AD - two thousand and seventy years ago - it is a treatise on political philosophy similar to The Republic by Plato, which contains another formidable aphorism: “Until philosophers rule as kings, or those who are nowadays called kings and leading men become genuine and adequate philosophers ... cities will have no rest from evils”.
101681_300
I will confess a grave sin: I had forgotten about Cicero, Plato and other giants of my Western, Italian culture. I freely admit: it took my reading a novel whose main character is Cicero to get me thinking about him again. The book isn't a masterpiece, but it appeared to me like a case of synchronicity. The “meaningful coincidences”, as the manifestations of this phenomenon are known, were numerous: in Cicero's Rome and today's Bangkok (where there is no Caesar let alone a Cicero, but plenty of Catilines), discussions abound on freedom and its limitations, coups d’état, patricians and plebeians, fortune-tellers and omens, tribunes of the people and consular candidates.
But these aren't the most meaningful coincidences. In the end, too much, or too little, is already being said about Thailand. The case of synchronicity led me to reflect again on the different ways of perceiving culture, civilisation and progress.
When I go back to Italy, or I speak to Italians travelling or living abroad, I often hear the same complaint: there is no difference between Thailand or other countries in the region and Europe, and especially Italy. In fact, Italy often comes out worse in the comparison. And more so when it comes to future predictions. But that is to forget that we experience the reality in countries such as Thailand in a privileged way. We look but we don't see, we don't analyse. In short, we don't know. The coup in Thailand, the introduction of sharia law in Brunei, and the human rights violations in Southeast Asian countries appear to us as marginal phenomena compared to the economic crisis that may yet mark the decline of the West. We are so focused on ourselves as to forget what we are a part of - our social system and our values.
We forget Cicero. We forget our culture and our reality. Or worse, we do not know the former and we cannot appreciate the latter. This is the one thing in which we are truly globalised, in a world of virtual reality where information is self-referential and where connection creates incommunicability.
It is a reflection that also works in the opposite direction, for others. Asians, especially Thais, justify inequalities, coups d’état, restrictions and human rights violations by affirming that their countries are not ready for democracy, that Western values cannot yet be applied to them. At the same time, however, they dispute those same values by talking up their proclaimed moral superiority that would derive from keeping their own values intact.
But it is precisely in the “intangible” goods - i.e. governance, innovation, the rule of law, welfare, freedom of ideas - that Europe can reaffirm its role, and define a cultural mode. Provided it has the conscience and capacity to do so.
Just like Cicero.
0 Comments

The illusions of poverty

Women sitting on their haunches, wearing colourful saris. A position of congenital elegance that many Western women try in vain to assume.
In Bangladesh it is one of the causes of uterine prolapse. Following early marriage, numerous pregnancies, or working in the fields.
They sit like this on the “Rongdhonu”, the ship that Greenpeace gave to Friendship, an organisation that aims to provide medical assistance in the poorest and most isolated areas of one of the world's poorest and most isolated countries. One of these areas, the very poorest and most isolated, is in the Bay of Bengal, where the Ganges and the Brahmaputra meet in an immense delta of swamps and lowlands. Regularly devastated by cyclones and submerged by seawater. A wet world where drinking water is hard to find.
Working-AreasP1010281
Some of these women are lucky: they are being operated on by a team of doctors from the United States. Others less so. Such as the one who perhaps has cancer – she doesn't know for sure, she may not find out until it is too late. She doesn't seem upset. In a place where the most common illness can be fatal, cancer is just another sickness. I watch her as she returns to land on board a nouka, a beaten up fishing boat, which ferries its load of women in saris between the shore and the hospital ship. As the distance grows, the scene begins to resemble a Gauguin painting. In places such as this, perspective, or distance, is no longer a point of view; it creates an illusory paradox.
P1010155
P1010260
Poverty creates beauty and pure beauty is made by poverty. Such as the woman dragging a net as she wades in the river. You don't feel the weight of the net or the mud on the riverbed, the effort that day after day causes her pelvic organs to collapse. You only see a colour reflected in the current.
On the deck of the Rongdhonu, though, you are up close: you smell the same smells, feel the same heat, see the women waiting in line or being stretchered back on deck after an operation: asleep, they are placed on a folding bed by other women because the men, according to the rules of Islam, cannot touch them. They will convalesce here, sheltered by a sheet of canvas, for two or three days. Under one of the beds, a catheter bag rests next to a pan of lentil dahl.
P1010143
It's yet another paradox: they have been operated on by a top team, which they may remember as if it were a dream, but are then immediately returned to their natural human condition.
The same happens, in reverse, for the all-female American doctors and nurses. They move between an operating room that, though limited, meets Western standards, and a gangway on the ship that looks increasingly like an old tramp steamer as the days pass. But they have no time to notice the contrast. These women are the demonstration that the impact between cultures can generate positive energy.
The mirages disappear as night falls. It's a quiet time. The stars are bright, with no land pollution to dim them. The air cools. A village atmosphere is recreated on deck: the patients are cared for by their relatives, some eat, some lie on a mat on the deck with their children beside them. The few men present murmur quietly amongst themselves.
On the bridge, the captain and a few members of the crew pray towards the west. The engineer brings me a dark, sweet tea, and I offer him a cigarette in return. He tells me that there are pirates further south, amongst the Sundarbans mangroves. Just down current from there, Bani Shanta, a strip of mud and huts, is home to about a hundred prostitutes. Both the pirates and the prostitutes rely on the traffic in the delta: the cargo ships carrying goods not worth the insurance and crews that are only valued by the prostitutes.
P1010415
"But it is beautiful here," concludes the engineer, throwing the last of my cigarettes into the river.
It truly is beautiful, but the nocturnal silence doesn't last. A storms rips through two hours later. The wind could well tear away the canvas sheltering the patients. It should be taken down, but the rain is torrential. The women and their families have to be taken indoors. They gather in any available space. The day's heat given off by the sheet metal stagnates. A few fans try to disperse it, but they soon stop because the on-board generator overloads.
This is no cyclone, or even a mid-monsoon tempest. It's just a storm, but it makes you understand the impact of a violent climate when all you have over your head is a bit of canvas or the roof of a hut, while the ground turns to mud. Big natural disasters kill tens of thousands of people in a short space of time, but this kind of weather also kills - just more slowly. It destroys you day by day, due to illness or the inability to repay a loan, which you may have taken out to set up a shrimp farm that was washed away by high tides.
On board the Rongdhonu, I find an article I set aside for this trip and then forgot. It is entitled Poor Choices. It's a review-reflection on certain essays that analyse the roots of extreme poverty, the condition of a billion people living on little more than a dollar a day. But also the inadequacy of our world to tackle the problem. “Poverty presents both a moral and an intellectual challenge,” I read. And while I read, I realise that the second is the most difficult to tackle. We have to overcome conceptual and cultural barriers that have almost become a moral law. Like the support for certain local NGOs used to enter politics. Or the mystical support for the microcredit system. We have to listen to Shushuma, a sixty-year-old woman who got a loan of 10,000 taka (about 95 euro) from the Grameen Bank at an interest rate of 18%. She gave the money to her son, for that shrimp farm.
0 Comments